Branchoria UFO Research Deaths UFO Research Deaths

Evidence-led scrutiny of deaths, disappearances and suppression claims around unconventional research.

Within Obituaries

Obituary Types Evide

Paid and professional obituaries can describe the same death while carrying very different evidentiary weight.

3 graphics
Preview for Obituary Types Evide

Introduction

Paid and professional obituaries can describe the same death while carrying very different evidentiary weight. In disputes involving UFO, antigravity and unconventional-research figures, the difference matters because an obituary may be used to support several separate claims: that a person died, that they had a particular scientific background, that they were involved in controversial research, or that their death was connected to that research. Those claims require different levels and types of evidence.

Obituary Types Evide illustration 1
Explanatory illustration 1

A paid death notice or funeral-home obituary is usually a first-party memorial source. It can be highly useful for confirming identity, relatives, funeral arrangements and the fact that a death was publicly announced. However, the information is generally supplied by family members or funeral representatives rather than independently investigated by journalists. By contrast, an editorial or professional obituary may involve reporting, institutional knowledge and authorship by colleagues who understand the deceased’s field. The additional authority is not unlimited, but it can make the source much stronger for questions about career history and professional reputation.[The Washington Post]helpcenter.washingtonpost.comThe Washington Post How to Place Death Notice or Obituary – The Washington PostThe Washington Post How to Place Death Notice or Obituary – The Washington Post

The key distinction is therefore not whether one obituary is “true” and another is “false”. It is whether the source is appropriate for the specific claim being tested.

Why the author of an obituary changes its evidentiary value

The word “obituary” covers several different types of documents. Newspapers often place paid announcements and editorial biographies in the same general section, which can create confusion for researchers using archives. The Washington Post explicitly separates the two: a paid death notice is a classified advertisement prepared by the family or funeral home, while a news obituary is a biographical article written by a reporter and published as journalism.[The Washington Post]helpcenter.washingtonpost.comThe Washington Post How to Place Death Notice or Obituary – The Washington PostThe Washington Post How to Place Death Notice or Obituary – The Washington Post

Legacy makes the same distinction, explaining that a death notice is normally a short publication containing details of the death, funeral services and memorial information, usually paid for by the family or funeral home. A traditional newspaper obituary, in contrast, is a life story normally written by a journalist. Legacy also notes that the terminology is frequently blurred in practice, with newspapers and readers sometimes using “obituary” for both types of publication.[Legacy]legacy.comDifference Between a Death Notice and Obituary | Obituary and EulogiesDifference Between a Death Notice and Obituary | Obituary and Eulogies…

That ambiguity creates a practical problem in disputed researcher deaths. A citation that says “the newspaper obituary reported…” may conceal an important difference. A newspaper may have hosted a text that was actually written and submitted by relatives. The credibility of the newspaper brand does not automatically transfer to every sentence inside a paid memorial notice.

For example, a family-written notice may be the strongest available source for:

  • the deceased person’s full name;
  • dates of birth and death;
  • surviving relatives;
  • funeral arrangements;
  • how the family wished to publicly remember the person.

The same notice may be a weak source for:

  • whether a scientific claim was valid;
  • whether a researcher’s work was accepted by specialists;
  • whether a death involved criminal activity;
  • whether a person was targeted because of their research.

The difference comes from the relationship between the author and the information. Relatives often have direct knowledge of family matters but are not necessarily independent evaluators of technical or historical claims.

What's the difference between Primary and Secondary Sources in History?

Channel: The Medieval Historian

Open on YouTube

Ning Li: a family memorial that resolves one question but not another

The case of physicist Ning Li demonstrates why obituary evidence must be separated by claim.

Li became associated with antigravity discussions after her earlier work on superconductivity and gravitational effects, and later online narratives treated her withdrawal from public scientific activity as mysterious. Her Berryhill Funeral Home obituary provides a clear public record of her death: it gives her dates as 14 January 1943 to 27 July 2021, states that she died in Huntsville, Alabama, identifies her son and grandchildren, and provides details of funeral arrangements.[Berryhill Funeral Home]berryhillfh.comBerryhill Funeral Home Ning Li ObituaryBerryhill Funeral HomeNing Li Obituary July 27, 2021 - Berryhill Funeral Home & CrematoryJuly 27, 2021…Published: July 27, 2021

For the narrow claim that Ning Li died and was not simply an indefinitely missing researcher, the funeral-home notice is valuable evidence. It establishes a dated memorial record connected to a specific person and location.

However, the same document illustrates the limits of family-supplied material. The obituary describes Li as “one of the world’s leading scientists in super-conductivity anti-gravity” and states that she constructed a 12-inch high-temperature superconducting device.[Berryhill Funeral Home]berryhillfh.comBerryhill Funeral Home Ning Li ObituaryBerryhill Funeral HomeNing Li Obituary July 27, 2021 - Berryhill Funeral Home & CrematoryJuly 27, 2021…Published: July 27, 2021 Those statements are evidence that the memorial presented Li in that way. They are not equivalent to independent scientific confirmation.

This distinction is especially important in unconventional research fields, where a person’s supporters, critics and later commentators may disagree sharply about the significance of past work. A funeral notice can accurately record that a family or community regarded someone as a pioneering researcher without independently proving that the underlying scientific claims were correct.

The later investigation by the Huntsville Business Journal demonstrates how different source types can work together. The publication examined the long-running questions surrounding Li’s disappearance from public view and interviewed her son, George Men, after locating information from the obituary. The reporting added context that the memorial notice itself did not provide.[Berryhill Funeral Home]berryhillfh.comBerryhill Funeral Home Ning Li ObituaryBerryhill Funeral HomeNing Li Obituary July 27, 2021 - Berryhill Funeral Home & CrematoryJuly 27, 2021…Published: July 27, 2021

The evidentiary lesson is clear: the funeral-home obituary was strong evidence for Li’s death and memorial identity, but it was not designed to answer every historical question surrounding her career.

Obituary Types Evide illustration 2
Explanatory illustration 2

James McDonald: professional obituary as evidence of scientific identity

James E. McDonald provides the opposite example because his obituary was embedded in a professional context.

McDonald was an atmospheric physicist at the University of Arizona who became one of the most prominent scientists to argue that UFO reports deserved serious investigation. His professional obituary in the Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society was written within his scientific community rather than supplied only by relatives. The obituary is valuable because it documents his conventional scientific career and his UFO investigations together, showing that the latter were not simply a reputation created decades later by enthusiasts.[Reddit]reddit.com7 May, Professor James Mc Donald Day! See comment7 May, Professor James McDonald Day! See comment:May 7, 2022…Published: May 7, 2022

For questions about McDonald’s professional identity, this type of source has advantages that a family notice would not. A colleague writing for a scientific audience is more likely to understand institutional roles, research fields and professional achievements. The obituary’s placement within a scientific publication also helps establish that McDonald’s UFO work was known among professional peers during his lifetime.[Reddit]reddit.com7 May, Professor James Mc Donald Day! See comment7 May, Professor James McDonald Day! See comment:May 7, 2022…Published: May 7, 2022

This matters because disputed histories often involve a question of whether a researcher was genuinely connected to a particular field or whether later communities exaggerated that connection. A professional obituary can be particularly useful for answering that question.

Yet even professional obituaries have boundaries. They are memorial documents, not forensic reports. A colleague may provide an informed account of a person’s achievements while still presenting a selective portrait shaped by respect and personal association. More importantly, an obituary’s authority over career history does not automatically extend to circumstances of death.

A professional society obituary can show that McDonald was a respected atmospheric scientist who investigated UFO reports. It cannot, by itself, establish why he died or whether his research played any role in his death.

Alternate Sources for Death Records | 5-Minute Find | Ancestry

Channel: Ancestry

Open on YouTube

Amy Eskridge: why publication venue alone is misleading

Amy Eskridge’s obituary shows why researchers must examine authorship rather than simply the website hosting the text.

The Legacy-hosted obituary records Eskridge’s death on 11 June 2022 and describes her education, family relationships and role as co-founder and president of the Institute for Exotic Science. It also contains memorial information and details about a celebration of life.[Legacy]legacy.comDifference Between a Death Notice and Obituary | Obituary and EulogiesDifference Between a Death Notice and Obituary | Obituary and Eulogies…

Those details are useful evidence for basic biography. They support the claim that Eskridge was publicly associated with unconventional-science interests and that a memorial notice identified her in that way.

However, the notice does not establish the cause or manner of her death. A memorial text that does not discuss cause of death cannot be used to infer that the death was suspicious, accidental, suicidal or connected to research.

This is a recurring problem in online discussions of disputed deaths. A page may contain an original obituary followed by later comments from members of the public. Those comments may express theories or suspicions, but they are separate from the original memorial document. Treating an entire obituary webpage as one unified source can unintentionally combine family statements with later speculation.

How to Analyze Primary Sources and Secondary Sources

Channel: Pursuit of History

Open on YouTube

Matching obituary type to the claim being tested

The most reliable approach is to match the source type to the question.

A paid notice is often strongest for confirming that a death occurred and documenting family-provided information. It can be particularly useful when investigating claims that a person vanished, because a dated memorial record can establish that the person later died and where that death was publicly recorded. Ning Li’s obituary is an example of this function.[Berryhill Funeral Home]berryhillfh.comBerryhill Funeral Home Ning Li ObituaryBerryhill Funeral HomeNing Li Obituary July 27, 2021 - Berryhill Funeral Home & CrematoryJuly 27, 2021…Published: July 27, 2021

A professional obituary is often stronger for claims about scientific reputation. James McDonald’s case demonstrates how a peer-written memorial can establish that a researcher’s unconventional interests were recognised within a broader professional life.[Reddit]reddit.com7 May, Professor James Mc Donald Day! See comment7 May, Professor James McDonald Day! See comment:May 7, 2022…Published: May 7, 2022

A family obituary may document how supporters or relatives understood a person’s achievements, but it should not automatically validate those achievements. Technical claims require technical evidence: publications, institutional records, experiments, peer review or independent reporting.

Neither type of obituary is normally the best source for criminal or forensic conclusions. Questions about homicide, suicide, accident or official investigations require records created for those purposes, such as medical examiner reports, police files or court documents.

Obituary Types Evide illustration 3
Explanatory illustration 3

Why obituary evidence is valuable but limited

Obituaries are important historical documents because they preserve information that can otherwise disappear. They can identify researchers, connect names to institutions, record family relationships and reveal how communities remembered individuals after death. In fields surrounded by controversy, they can also correct simple factual errors, such as claims that someone disappeared permanently when a later death record exists.

But their value depends on restraint. A paid memorial notice and a professional obituary are not interchangeable. One may be closest to the family’s knowledge; the other may be closest to the professional community’s assessment. Both can be useful, but they answer different questions.

For disputed deaths among UFO and antigravity researchers, the strongest analysis treats obituaries as layered evidence. The right question is not whether an obituary exists, but who produced it, what they were positioned to know and whether the claim being made falls within that source’s actual evidentiary strength.

Amazon book picks

Further Reading

Books and field guides related to Obituary Types Evide. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.

BookCover for The Craft of Research

The Craft of Research

By Wayne C. Booth, Gregory G. Colomb et al.

Rating: 4.3/5 from 6 Google Books ratings

Since 1995, students, researchers, and professionals have turned to The Craft of Research for clear and helpful guidance on how to conduc...

See on Amazon
Browse more on Amazon:The Dead Beat: Lost Souls, Lucky Stiffs, and the Perverse Pleasures of ObituariesObit: Inspiring Stories of Ordinary People Who Led Extraordinary LivesThe Craft of Research

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

eBay marketplace picks

Marketplace Samples

Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.

UsingUSA

Selected fromUFO poster oneBay.co.uk.

Browse more oneBay.co.uk

Example items shown for inspiration; availability and pricing can change. Branchoria may earn a commission if you purchase through outbound eBay links.

Endnotes

1. Source: legacy.com
Title: Difference Between a Death Notice and Obituary | Obituary and Eulogies
Link:https://www.legacy.com/memorial-writing/difference-between-a-death-notice-and-obituary

Source snippet

Difference Between a Death Notice and Obituary | Obituary and Eulogies...

2. Source: reddit.com
Title: 7 May, Professor James Mc Donald Day! See comment
Link:https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOB/comments/uk7kbn

Source snippet

7 May, Professor James McDonald Day! See comment:May 7, 2022...

Published: May 7, 2022

3. Source: legacy.com
Title: What’s the Difference Between an Obituary and a Death Notice? | Advice & Support
Link:https://www.legacy.com/advice/whats-the-difference-between-an-obituary-and-a-death-notice

4. Source: helpcenter.washingtonpost.com
Title: The Washington Post How to Place Death Notice or Obituary – The Washington Post
Link:https://helpcenter.washingtonpost.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003676568-How-to-Place-Death-Notice-or-Obituary

5. Source: berryhillfh.com
Title: Berryhill Funeral Home Ning Li Obituary
Link:https://www.berryhillfh.com/obituary/ning-li?lud=4CF765EE88E7526FCBA619C30101F7E6

Source snippet

Berryhill Funeral HomeNing Li Obituary July 27, 2021 - Berryhill Funeral Home & CrematoryJuly 27, 2021...

Published: July 27, 2021

6. Source: legacytrail.co.uk
Title: Death notices and obituaries in the UK: what they are and how to place one
Link:https://legacytrail.co.uk/guides/funeral-planning/death-notices-and-obituaries-in-the-uk-what-they-are-and-how-to-place-one

Source snippet

Guides 2. Funeral Planning 3. Death notices and obituaries in the UK: what they are and how to place one DEATH NOTICES AND OBITUARIES IN...

7. Source: berryhillfh.com
Title: Nicole Leigh Berryhill Obituary
Link:https://www.berryhillfh.com/obituaries/nicole-berryhill

8. Source: berryhillfh.com
Title: Ning Li Obituary
Link:https://www.berryhillfh.com/guestbook/ning-li

9. Source: berryhillfh.com
Title: Ning Li Obituary
Link:https://www.berryhillfh.com/obituary/ning-li/print

10. Source: washingtonpost.com
Title: Opinion | The Craft of Telling Life Stories
Link:https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/2006/04/09/the-craft-of-telling-life-stories/ab110090-8473-4baa-862e-91f4302a1f1f/

11. Source: washingtonpost.com
Title: WHER E TO CALL
Link:https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/2003/04/14/where-to-call/d3180df5-c83a-4345-ad3b-1f11e0be0326/

12. Source: washingtonpost.com
Title: For Your Information
Link:https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/2002/08/30/for-your-information/8938c0c8-5853-4e22-8546-4c4737b31279/

13. Source: washingtonpost.com
Title: Opinion | The Art of the Obit
Link:https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/2002/02/10/the-art-of-the-obit/f46a419e-d5f9-4a20-968a-169eec268bd5/

14. Source: berryhillfh.com
Link:https://www.berryhillfh.com/obits

15. Source: selfserviceadvertising.washingtonpost.com
Link:https://selfserviceadvertising.washingtonpost.com/adportal/obits/info/faqs.htm

16. Source: selfserviceadvertising.washingtonpost.com
Link:https://selfserviceadvertising.washingtonpost.com/adportal/obits/info/deadlines.htm

17. Source: tributearchive.com
Title: ning li
Link:https://www.tributearchive.com/obituaries/32826463/ning-li

18. Source: files.ncas.org
Link:https://files.ncas.org/ufosymposium/mcdonald.html

Additional References

19. Source: newspaperarchive.com
Title: What’s the Difference Between an Obituary, Funeral Notice, and Death Notice?
Link:https://newspaperarchive.com/blog/what-s-the-difference-between-an-obituary-funeral-notice-and-death-notice/

Source snippet

NewspaperArchive BlogMay 7, 2026 — Image: Three labeled newspaper examples comparing an obituary, death notice, and funeral notice for...

Published: May 7, 2026

20. Source: afterloss.uk
Title: It serves three purposes: notifying people who
Link:https://www.afterloss.uk/wiki/guides/publishing-a-death-notice/

Source snippet

Publishing a death notice in the UK: where, how and what to include - AfterLoss WikiApril 30, 2026 — PUBLISHING A DEATH NOTICE IN THE UK...

Published: April 30, 2026

21. Source: youtube.com
Title: How to Analyze Primary Sources and Secondary Sources
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WTA-QNOGK1M

Source snippet

Genealogy obituaries paid vs editorial death notices source evaluation Serial Killers Explain Why They Killed😰 #shorts #tiktok...

22. Source: youtube.com
Title: What’s the difference between Primary and Secondary Sources in History?
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XU0fAhss-yg

Source snippet

How to Analyze Primary Sources and Secondary Sources...

23. Source: shinysideout.com.au
Link:https://www.shinysideout.com.au/13-ning-li.html

24. Source: expandingfrontiersresearch.org
Link:https://www.expandingfrontiersresearch.org/items-1/ann-druffel-special-collection

25. Source: linkedin.com
Link:https://www.linkedin.com/posts/glen-a-robertson-b66bb7b9_obituary-for-ning-li-at-berryhill-funeral-activity-6837614336169574400-QPah

26. Source: youtube.com
Title: Alternate Sources for Death Records
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GoKe8rb20ZM

Source snippet

What's the difference between Primary and Secondary Sources in History?...

27. Source: youtube.com
Title: Complete and Accurate Citation of Sources | Genealogical Proof Standard
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8WlI7D3eBE

Source snippet

Rating Your Genealogy Sources...

28. Source: theufochronicles.com
Title: Science and UFOs: Part 1—The Condon Committee Con Job
Link:https://www.theufochronicles.com/2012/03/science-and-ufos-part-1the-condon.html